‘Idiotic’ and ‘cruel’ Victoria police welfare policy leaves detainees too tired for a fair trial, judge says

Hourly night-time welfare checks left detainees so sleep deprived that it risked their right to a fair trial, supreme court judge found

• Follow our Australia news live blog for latest updates

• Get our breaking news email, free app or daily news podcast

A Victorian supreme court judge has strongly criticised police for the “idiotic” and “cruel” practice of unnecessarily waking up people in custody during the night under the guise of welfare checks.

Justice Michael Croucher said Victoria police needed to rethink its approach or it would result in the end of criminal trials “of any substantial duration” in regional courts where the accused had to be held in the local police station.