Christmas lights, holiday markets and winter wonderlands usually spread cheer — but some of the country’s most popular attractions have also delivered a frustrating experience for many Americans, according to Tripadvisor reviews.
Visitors cite everything from massive crowds and long waits to high prices and underwhelming displays in their negative ratings posted on the review site.
The list was compiled by Nomad eSIM, a global digital service that analyzed Tripadvisor data. It ranked U.S. Christmas attractions by the volume of one- and two-star reviews the locations received.
TOP TRAVEL DESTINATIONS GAINING BUZZ FOR 2026 TRIPS REVEALED IN NEW REPORT
Criticism or not, many of these attractions remain wildly popular. Fox News Digital reached out to each of the venues for comment.
Here’s a look at America’s most "disappointing" Christmas attractions, according to the compiled list.
The holiday venue in Branson includes more than 6.5 million lights, Broadway-style performances, craft demonstrations and traditional seasonal meals, according to the park’s website.
Even so, the park received the most low-rated reviews of all U.S. Christmas attractions on Tripadvisor.
Visitors most frequently cited long wait times, heavy crowding and dissatisfaction with food and entertainment offerings during peak holiday periods.
MEGA-FANS SWARM QUAINT NEW ENGLAND TOWNS, CHASING CHRISTMAS MOVIE CHARM
One reviewer from Ohio said their family of 14 spent roughly $1,500 on tickets and add-ons during a holiday visit — describing the experience as poorly managed.
Another visitor wrote, "Absolutely the worst experience we have ever had at an amusement park," noting three-hour wait times, overcrowding and limited access to food and seating.
Santa Claus House describes itself as a year-round attraction.
It offers Santa meet-and-greets, Christmas-themed merchandise and seasonal displays in the town of North Pole, Alaska, according to the attraction’s website.
The attraction received the second-highest number of low-rated reviews among U.S. Christmas destinations on Tripadvisor.
Reviewers mentioned the experience as overpriced and limited in scope.
One reviewer wrote, "Don’t make this anything but a bathroom stop."
THE TOP 10 CHRISTMAS CITIES IN THE US, WITH A SURPRISE CITY AS THE WINNER
Paul Brown, the venue's operations manager, told Fox News Digital, "While it makes for a sensational headline, this ‘report' from Nomad certainly stretches the truth to get there. For example, see our overall 4.1-star rating on TripAdvisor and the fact that we have consistently been a ‘Best of TripAdvisor.’ [We] are currently a Travelers’ Choice — which means we’re ranked ‘in the Top 10% of properties on TripAdvisor.’"
Brown said that while the location takes "all customer feedback seriously, we also consider the context. Regarding the online review sites … the number of reviews in this case is a small percentage of the traffic we get even on a daily basis, so it is hardly representative of overall guest satisfaction,"
He added, "We like to think we must be doing something right, or we wouldn’t be celebrating our 73rd Christmas this year."
The Wheeling venue features a nightly drive-through holiday light display, along with additional seasonal attractions such as Santa’s Village and Christmas-themed activities at the park’s zoo, its website notes.
CLICK HERE FOR MORE LIFESTYLE STORIES
The attraction received the third-highest number of low-rated reviews among U.S. Christmas destinations on Tripadvisor.
Visitors were unhappy about long wait times to enter the park, particularly during peak holiday evenings, as well as disappointed with portions of the light display.
One reviewer said the trip was the "biggest waste of time to drive four hours to see a pathetic light display."
Other visitors called the experience "awful" and "overrated."
This seasonal drive-through holiday attraction is held inside the Louisville Mega Cavern, a former limestone mine located roughly 100 feet beneath the city.
The event features illuminated displays along a route that takes vehicles through underground caverns, the attraction’s website said.
TEST YOURSELF WITH OUR LATEST LIFESTYLE QUIZ
The attraction received the fourth-highest number of low-rated reviews among U.S. Christmas destinations on Tripadvisor. Complaints centered on long wait times and disappointment with the display.
One reviewer called it "an expensive light show that didn’t feel very Christmas-themed."
Another visitor said the experience did not compare favorably to other holiday light events the person had attended.
Christkindlmarkt is a seasonal Christmas market often referred to as "Christmas City." It features European-style vendors, handcrafted goods and holiday food offerings, the event’s website said.
The market received the fifth-highest number of low-rated reviews among U.S. Christmas attractions on Tripadvisor.
Multiple reviewers pointed to high entry fees, crowded walkways and the cost of food and merchandise, with several reviewers questioning whether the experience justified the price.
One reviewer wrote, "You pay $15 just to enter, and the prices inside were more than double what I’ve paid elsewhere."
Another visitor said, "After experiencing real German Christmas markets, this one falls very short."
In comments to Fox News Digital, the venue said its "continued growth plays a vital role in supporting our nonprofit mission and helps us provide nearly 40% of our arts and cultural programming free to the public."
It also pointed out that "ArtsQuest’s Christkindlmarkt 2025 was rated the No. 4 Christmas market in the nation by USAToday in 2025, and has been in the Top 10 since 2019. Additionally, Bethlehem was ranked No. 1 [among] affordable Christmas destinations for 2025 [by] HomeToGo, a global vacation marketplace that tracks travel trends."
The organization also said, "While we can appreciate reviews calling attention to crowds, increased attendance and the popularity of Christkindlmarkt speak directly to the value and success of our mission: to make artistic and cultural experiences more accessible to all. In addition to our regular admission, we
are proud to have offered five free Fridays this year, which were enjoyed by 21,199 visitors."
CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR LIFESTYLE NEWSLETTER
"This year’s Christkindlmarkt marked an exciting new chapter," said Kassie Hilgert, president and CEO of ArtsQuest told Fox News Digital. "The debut of Winter Wonderland allowed us to expand the experience into a truly immersive holiday village, creating more space, more magic and more opportunities for our community and visitors to gather, celebrate and make memories together."
While these attractions received many low-rated reviews, they also continue to attract large numbers of visitors each year — which can contribute to higher expectations.
