Downton Abbey star’s TV thriller races up Netflix chart despite being branded ‘waste of time’

Published 3 hours ago
Source: metro.co.uk
Allen Leech as ELLIOT FIELDING
Allen Leech stars in Channel 5’s Too Good to Be True (Picture: Steffan Hill/Channel 5/Story Films)

One of the stars of Downton Abbey has seen Netflix thriller storm the top 10 charts on the streaming platform.

However, not all viewers are fans of the Channel 5 drama, claiming that its plot is too ‘predictable’.

Allen Leech might be best known to you as Downton’s Tom Branson, but in Channel 5’s Too Good To Be True, the 44-year-old takes an extremely different turn.

Playing the role of Elliot, his character offers single mother Rachel (EastEnders star Kara Tointon), who is trying to make ends meet as a cleaner, a lucrative cleaning job.

But in this twisty thriller, which originally aired on Channel 5 as Too Good to Be True before being added to Netflix where it’s available to stream under the title Captivated, not everything is as it seems.

Get personalised updates on all things Netflix

Wake up to find news on your TV shows in your inbox every morning with Metro’s TV Newsletter.

Sign up to our newsletter and then select your show in the link we’ll send you so we can get TV news tailored to you.

In addition to Tointon and Leech, the cast for the four-part series includes Silent Witness star Sara Powell, Line of Duty’s Taj Atwal and Coronation Street actor John Thomson.

4226_D018_01935-01936_RCC Allen Leech stars as Tom Branson and Michelle Dockery as Lady Mary in DOWNTON ABBEY: The Grand Finale, a Focus Features release. Credit: Rory Mulvey / ?? 2025 FOCUS FEATURES LLC
Leech will be best known to viewers as Tom Branson in Downton Abbey (Picture: Rory Mulvey)

Despite its second place ranking on the top 10 Netflix shows in the UK, viewers were less than impressed with the series, as antide-47567 wrote on IMDb: ‘It is very predictable and some of it makes no sense at all.’

With a rating of 5.6 on the website, Vindelander also claimed that it was an ‘utter waste of time’, arguing: ‘It gets steadily worse with each episode with a paper thin and entirely predictable plot.’

Meanwhile, IGreen-23696 commented: ‘So predictable. Hopeless acting. Was hoping for a twist, turn or some surprise. No, just utterly boring.’

Yet, while many criticised the series, some in fact argued that it was ‘better than expected’, as Sleepin_Dragon wrote: ‘I’ve read some scathing reviews about this show, and whilst I don’t think it’s great, I still think it’s watchable.’

Have you heard of these hidden gems?

In what has been a very strong year for TV, not everybody has the time to binge all the latest releases.

From the likes of The Lowdown to The Chair Company, here are the seven best TV shows from this year that you’ve probably missed.

Chloe Galley similarly said: ‘Despite the low rating and some negative reviews it’s surprisingly good. So don’t be fooled.’

Gvbackel backed up this sentiment by adding: ‘I must say I was captivated by this series. Even though it has some weak points in my opinion, it was the interplay between the mother, her son, and her best friend, that I found endearing.’

POLL
Poll

Are you intrigued to give the thriller Captivated a go?

  • YesCheck
  • NoCheck
Too Good To Be True - Channel 5 Pictured Kara Tointon
The Netflix thriller originally aired on Channel 5 as Too Good To Be True (Picture: Channel 5)
Too Good To Be True, 9pm, Ch5 Kara Tointon as RACHEL ? Steffan Hill 2023, Press Enquiries: press@channel5.com NOTE: Channel 5 images are for the use of Press outlets only. Any blogs , requesting access to these images are required to seek approval from Channel 5 directly. Contact press@channel5.com, While we will continue to send out the weekly PI booklet every Friday, we have now launched the ViacomCBS Media Hub. This is an all-encompassing press centre where you can find the latest PI, press releases and other relevant informati
Despite the bad reviews, the show – which stars EastEnders actress Kara Tointon – has surged up Netflix’s charts (Picture: Steffan Hill/Channel 5/Story Films)

The show’s official synopsis reads: ‘Rachel, a single mother and cleaner, is offered a better job by a wealthy businessman.

‘She accepts, but grows suspicious of his motives as she becomes more involved in his affairs.’

Its success on Netflix comes after another show topped charts in 76 countries despite its terrible Rotten Tomatoes score.

Emily in Paris season five has been labelled ‘garbage’ and ‘terrible’ by critics, but according to FlixPatrol, the show has reached the dizzying heights of the number one spot in the Netflix charts.

Starring Lily Collins as a marketing executive, the latest instalment of the hit show sees Emily swap Paris for Rome.

Too Good To Be True is available to stream on Netflix.

Got a story?

If you’ve got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us [email protected], calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we’d love to hear from you.

Categories

EntertainmentTVChannel 5Downton AbbeyNetflix